Unconditional devotion: Hubbard Hall’s ‘Sylvia’ captures the heart of mid-life longing – with laughter to boot

By TELLY HALKIAS

Vermont News & Media Correspondent

October 15, 2026 – CAMBRIDGE, N.Y. – There is a distinct magic that happens when a classic piece of American theater finds its perfect home, and that is precisely what occurred during Hubbard Hall’s recent fall season opener with a production of A.R. Gurney’s “Sylvia.”

Nestled within their historic 1878 Opera House in Cambridge, N.Y., this staging of Gurney’s beloved 1995 Off-Broadway comedy offered a production that was as deeply moving as it was howlingly funny. Under the sharp direction of Bennington College Faculty Emeritus Kirk Jackson, the production struck an exquisite balance between madcap canine satire and a tender meditation on aging, marriage, and human connection.

At the center of Gurney’s narrative are Greg (Shawn Paper) and Kate (Sarah Murphy) an empty-nest couple navigating a major life transition. Having spent 22 years raising children in the suburbs, they’ve recently relocated to Manhattan. Kate’s career as a public school English teacher is rising to new and exciting heights, giving her a fresh sense of purpose. Greg, conversely, finds his career as a financial trader winding down into an exhausting, soul-crushing drag. He finds himself adrift in a profound mid-life crisis until a chance encounter in Central Park changes everything.

Enter Sylvia (Jewel Winant): a street-smart, expressive stray dog, who bears nothing but her name on her collar. When Greg brings her back to their apartment, Sylvia becomes an immediate bone of contention. To Greg, she represents an escape from societal expectations and a source of unconditional love; to Kate, she is a loud, destructive, and deeply unwanted rival for her husband’s dwindling attention.

The success of “Sylvia” hinges on the actress inhabiting the titular canine, and Winant delivered a performance that can only be described as a masterclass in physical comedy. Winant bypassed any cheap, caricature-driven dog impressions, instead relying on an astonishing display of sheer athleticism and nuanced body language to convey the essence of a canine companion. From her hyper-alert posture when detecting a passing cat to the hilarious, unbridled joy of being scratched behind the ears, Winant kept the audience entirely captivated. Her verbal sparring with the rest of the cast was razor-sharp, transitioning seamlessly from streetwise sass to absolute vulnerability. It was a bravura turn that anchored the emotional stakes of the entire show.

As Greg, Paper grounded the production with a beautifully layered performance. Paper played Greg not as a clichéd, disaffected husband, but as a man genuinely mourning the loss of his youth and searching for meaning in a world that feels increasingly detached. His scenes with Winant were filled with an authentic, quiet warmth that made his character’s fierce devotion to the dog entirely believable.

Opposite him, the absolutely stunning Murphy brought remarkable depth and dignity to Kate. It’s easy for an actress to play Kate as a shrill, villainous spoilsport, but Murphy infused the role with intelligence and a profound sense of hurt. Her frustration was rooted not in malice, but in a real fear of losing the partner she spent decades building a life with. Murphy’s final scenes, where Kate begins to find peace with Sylvia, were handled with a beautiful, understated grace.

But, wait! There’s more. The comedic heavy lifting of the supporting characters fell entirely upon Debbie Warnock, who masterfully tackled a trio of wildly different roles. Warnock first appeared as Tom, a fellow dog owner in the park who dispenses pragmatic, hyper-masculine philosophies on canine dynamics. Later, she transformed into Phyllis, a wealthy, upper-crust Manhattan socialite whose sophisticated visit is thoroughly derailed by Sylvia’s over-enthusiastic sniffing. Finally, Warnock drew uproarious laughter as Leslie, an ambiguous, gender-fluid marriage counselor who becomes visibly traumatized by Greg’s bizarre obsession. Warnock’s chameleon-like versatility and impeccable comic timing provided the production with some of its most explosive laughs. Bravo!

On the technical side, the production’s atmosphere was masterful. Charles J.I. Krawczyk crafted a wonderfully minimalist set that allowed the narrative to shift effortlessly from a sleek Manhattan apartment to the open pathways of Central Park without overwhelming the intimate historic space. This canvas was enhanced by the rich, warm atmospheres designed by lighting designer Vera Schulman, alongside the dynamic modern touches of Dan Costello’s projection and light design.

Musical director and pianist Richard Cherry provided an exquisite, live tapestry that accentuated the play’s emotional high notes. Costume designer Neely Dessaint cleverly captured the characters’ personalities, blending sophisticated urban attire with several hilariously metaphorical looks for Sylvia herself. Behind the scenes, intimacy director Madeline Johns handled the cast’s complex physical boundaries with utmost care, while production stage manager Maureen Cossey, deftly assisted by Betsy Wilcox, ensured the fast-paced show ran with fluid precision.

Hubbard Hall has been through some difficult transition the last few years, and so its fall season opener of “Sylvia,” under the revitalizing aegis of interim artistic director Dan Costello, reminded us why theater remains such a vital medium for examining the human condition. This, even in rural, small-town venues, where the packed house also reflected a good part of the audience from across the nearby Vermont border. It’s a real draw, and Hubbard Hall is making it happen once again.

Beyond the laughter generated by Gurney’s cleverly funny script, the production left the audience with a poignant realization about the nature of love and the passage of time. Dogs, and other pets as well, occupy a uniquely heartbreaking space in our lives: they love us with an intensity that exceeds our capacity to return it, yet their time with us is agonizingly brief.

Hubbard Hall’s exquisite production captured that bittersweet truth perfectly, sending its audience out into the autumn night with damp eyes, broad smiles, and a deep urge to return the love to those in our lives – both two-legged, and four.

Hubbard Hall is located at 25 East Main St., Cambridge, N.Y. For more information on its complete fall programming, call 518-677-2495, or visit hubbardhall.org

—Telly Halkias is a national award-winning freelance journalist.. E-mail: tchalkias@aol.com X: @TellyHalkias

Click here for a full list of the Cast and Creative Team

Photo credits Mackenzie Spencer